Chinese American Equalization Association Demands Electoral Changes


Mayor Tom Beck says the city was unaware there was a problem, but is taking the matter seriously. – Photo by Terry Miller


By Katta Hules

Arcadia has been asked to change its electoral process. The HQH Chinese American Equalization Association (HQH CAEA) alleges the city is in violation of the California Voting Rights Act and should convert from at-large voting to a by-district system to allow more Asian American representation on the council. “My client is doing this in the best interest of the city … to make sure that everyone in the city has a say,” says the group’s attorney Richard McDonald.

Mayor Tom Beck says the city was unaware there was a problem, but is taking the matter seriously. They allocated funds to hire a demographics expert while Beck meets with Arcadia’s Asian leaders. “What I want to learn is, are they happy with the way things are? Do they want districts? What can we do to get more Asians on the city council?”

McDonald says HQH CAEA, a non-profit advocate group for a “united Asian American Community” according its Facebook page, has “received, over time, a number of complaints about the fact that there were so few Asian American city councilpeople.” There are a couple events contributing to the demand’s timing. “One, is I believe they did talk to the city earlier. Two, I believe there is a new law that created an opportunity for the city to address this.”

The law, last year’s SB 493, allows “a city with a population of fewer than 100,000 people to adopt an ordinance that requires the members of the legislative body to be elected by district” without going to the voters, the Bill states. As of last July, the Census estimated Arcadia’s population as 58,408 and 59.2 percent Asian.

The current at-large system allows any voter to vote for any candidate on the ballot. Elected officials then serve “the population of the city as a whole,” according to the National League of Cities website, a resource and advocate site for city leaders.

“If you are running at-large, you’re going to try to find the two or three thousand most likely voters, which … more often than not, are, only one geographic part of the city and so you end up then with one geographic part of the city electing the majority of the city council,” says McDonald, who served on Pasadena’s redistricting taskforce in 2001 and 2011.

Meanwhile, district candidates can only be voted for people in their area. “If you represent a district, you’re only interested in that district and what limited taxpayer money can you get for [it],” says Beck.

He is concerned districting could “polarize the city.” But, should Beck learn from analysis and outreach “that we have a problem, then I’m open to changing.”

McDonald says HQH CAEA wants to avoid litigation. “They hope everybody would agree it is a worthy goal and that is that by going to district elections, you improve your accountability, you improve your participation, you improve the overall transparency … make sure that everyone is getting represented.” However, they are prepared to pursue a lawsuit.

November 10, 2016

About Author

Arcadia Weekly Our team focuses on delivering you the most informative and interesting articles from a variety of sections to keep you well-informed on what's happening in the local community.

3 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Chinese American Equalization Association Demands Electoral Changes”

  1. Sherrie Powell Russo says:

    Sheng Chang ran last election, why didn’t those 59.2% elect him. Or Bob Harbicht, for that matter.
    I’m not sure how those 59.2% can realLy benefit by districting when they live in all parts of Arcadia, not one particular area of the city.

  2. Another Long Time Resident says:

    Shouldn’t we work to unite rather than divide our city?

  3. Raymond Cheung says:

    No one can argue that having 1 out of 5 Council seats in a city with 60% of the population is of Asian descent is truly representative, at least demographically. However, by-district elections isn’t going to solve the two root causes of under-representation, which is a lack of candidates and lack of voter participation. If any group is really interested in changing the status-quo, they should identify and encourage good, independent candidates to run for office, ensure they are funded appropriately, and establish get out the vote drives. That, and not a lawsuit, would go much farther in creating equal representation within our elected body.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *